The ECG Quiz User Manual

Site Tools


Action disabled: backlink
afibaflut

Distinguishing Atrial Flutter vs. Atrial Fibrillation on the ECG

Atrial flutter (AFL) and atrial fibrillation (AFib) are two of the most common supraventricular arrhythmias. Correctly differentiating them is important because:

  • Typical atrial flutter has a high success rate with catheter ablation
  • Atypical flutter and atrial fibrillation require different ablation strategies
  • Rhythm interpretation can guide anticoagulation, rate control, and EP referral

This page outlines ECG characteristics, diagnostic tips, and examples.

Primary References:


Atrial Flutter

Atrial flutter is usually a macro–reentrant circuit in the right atrium, producing rapid, regular atrial depolarizations.

Key ECG Features

  • Atrial rate ~300 bpm (range 200–400 bpm)
  • Ventricular rate ~150 bpm with 2:1 AV conduction
  • Regular rhythm
  • Absence of P waves
  • Saw-tooth “flutter waves” (F-waves) in inferior leads: II, III, aVF
  • F-wave polarity pattern:
    • Typical (Counterclockwise) Flutter:
      • Negative flutter waves in II, III, aVF
      • Positive flutter waves in V1
    • Reverse (Clockwise) Flutter:
      • Positive in II, III, aVF
      • Negative in V1

Types of Atrial Flutter

  • Typical (Type I): Cavotricuspid isthmus (CTI) dependent; highly ablation-curable
  • Atypical (Type II): Non-CTI circuits (left atrial, postoperative, scar-related); variable ECG morphology

Atypical flutter may appear irregular if AV conduction varies, mimicking AFib.


Atrial Fibrillation

Atrial fibrillation is characterized by chaotic, disorganized atrial activation.

Key ECG Features

  • No distinct P waves
  • Atrial rate: 400–600 bpm
  • Ventricular rhythm is “irregularly irregular”
  • Variable R-R intervals
  • “Fibrillatory (f) waves” present, low amplitude
  • Coarse AF: f-wave amplitude > 0.5 mm (can mimic flutter)

ECG signs supportive of AFib:

  • Highly variable AV conduction
  • Baseline undulations without repeating pattern
  • Absence of consistent flutter waves

Distinguishing Atrial Flutter vs Atrial Fibrillation

Feature Atrial Flutter Atrial Fibrillation
Rhythm Regular (unless variable block) Irregularly irregular
Atrial rate ~300 bpm 400–600 bpm
Baseline Saw-tooth flutter waves Chaotic, uneven baseline
P waves None None
F waves Organized, repetitive Disorganized, variable
R-R interval Regular with fixed block (e.g., 2:1) Irregular, unpredictable
Typical lead patterns II, III, aVF (saw-tooth) No consistent morphology
Response to vagal maneuvers May increase AV block → reveals flutter waves Minimal organized effect
Ablation success High in typical flutter Lower in AFib
Anticoagulation Required if persistent or risk factors Required based on CHA₂DS₂-VASc

Special Case: Coarse Atrial Fibrillation

Sometimes AFib produces large amplitude f-waves (>0.5 mm), creating confusion with atypical flutter.

How to differentiate:

  • AFib: Lacks regularity; waveforms vary beat-to-beat
  • Flutter: Organized, consistent F-wave pattern
  • AFib: Atrial rate typically faster (400–600 bpm)
  • Flutter: Atrial rate 200–400 bpm, usually near 300
  • Flutter shows stable repeating morphology
  • AFib does not

Practical Tips for Distinguishing AFL vs AFib

  • Look in inferior leads (II, III, aVF) where flutter waves are most pronounced
  • Check lead V1, where flutter often appears positive (typical)
  • Assess regularity of the R-R interval
  • Perform manual caliper measurement of the flutter cycle length (~200 ms)
  • In uncertain cases, try:
    • Adenosine (if safe) → reveals flutter waves by slowing AV node
    • Vagal maneuvers → may expose flutter waves

Sample ECG Images

Typical Atrial Flutter (2:1 Conduction)

Image to be added soon.

Atrial Fibrillation (Irregularly Irregular Rhythm)

Image to be added soon.

Coarse Atrial Fibrillation (Flutter Mimic)

Image to be added soon.


Key Takeaways

  • Atrial flutter has an organized, repeating pattern, usually around 300 bpm.
  • Atrial fibrillation shows disorganized atrial activity with irregularly irregular ventricular response.
  • Coarse AFib may resemble flutter but lacks stable morphology.
  • Typical flutter is highly curable with ablation; AFib treatment is more complex.
  • Using leads II, III, aVF, and V1 greatly improves diagnostic accuracy.
  • When uncertain, evaluate rhythm regularity, flutter cycle length, and use AV nodal slowing if appropriate.

afibaflut.txt · Last modified: 2025/11/27 19:35 by dtong

Page Tools